Rear Admiral P. Dean Mcfadden joined me on air this morning with Commander Mike Considine. At issue were Natal day celebrations in Halifax and the Navy’s more proactive interface with the public and also the news story of the day concerning Halifax peace activists protesting nuclear armed ships in Maritime harbours; the elephant in the room always is the media’s relationship with the military and its role.
Basically, the media’s response is divided into two camps: first, those that are circumspect about budgets and the application of force and squeamishness about combat ops; second, those in the media who are cheerleaders.
While I will always question policy, and our assumptions for policy, I will never prevaricate; the military has been screwed over on budgets and it has been repeatedly starved. Which raises the question: who really cares about our military?
In the 1990s the Liberal Party and the Conservatives and the government-of-the-day betrayed Canadian soldiers who served in Bosnia when a firefight broke out with Croatians in the Medak pocket. No one wanted to hear about blue helmets killing murderous Croatians. But there it was, all covered up by Ottawa. Soldiers returned home from combat with the shock of seeing rape and internecine tribal and religious warfare to a country that did not give them post traumatic stress help. Many of those same soldiers who fought there are today destroyed human beings: homeless, health problems, unemployable. Carol Off wrote about it in her book, Ghosts of The Medak Pocket. I interviewed her. While she’s a big lefty in the political and social arenas alike, she was horrified by how Canada turned its collective back. The horrific Medak pocket vets scenario became our version of the Vietnam vets, and sadly it was a story ignored — one too few Canadians are attuned too, to this very day.
“Never abandon your own.” The motto seemed good on a public relations front, but our government never seemed to practice what they preached.
But Canada’s betrayal of the military goes further than that. It is also cultural: the NDP would like to see our forces, and I say this hyperbolically, in Girl Guide uniforms — care bears. And this is not reality. There’s no place for cookies on the war lines.
We are a defacto American protectorate; before that we were a British protectorate. But America’s power is eroding in the world; America, both economically and militarily, is in contraction mode. So how will Canada respond?
The Japanese are rearming against China.
India is arming.
Iran is going for nukes; Saudi Arabia is nervous. There are security competitions brewing in all hot spots. We have Russians planting flags in our arctic today. Simply put, it is a different world now. The free ride is over for Canadian taxpayers when it comes to defense. One of my favorite professors of international relations, John Mersheimer, at the University of Chicago, points out that a multi-polar world is infinitely more dangerous than what was the bi-polar world of the Cold war.
Admiral McFadden, genial, tough, a Canadian patriarch if ever there was one, articulated his vision of a more open debate about defense in our society, and the role of the media. The truest measure of his soldiering was the honest revelation that Rear Admiral Mcfadden would rather have you vote for the Green Party than none at all; he is not afraid of the process. He is prepared to die for it.
However misguided or undermining civilian policies may sometimes appear, past or present, the Admiral is humble, ultimately, and acquiesces to public discourse and democratic process. Civilian control, no matter how hair-pulling, is what our society is about.
Think about what those poor U.S. Generals had to endure under Sec. Defense Rumsfeld. Finally, the Joint Chiefs told him to go to hell – and let the President know.
While this country does not have the same acrimony over civilian oversight (Powell and the rest were/are always more reluctant to send the boys in to harm’s way than their civilian overlords), we sometimes come close through emotional abandonment.